[6.0] "As is tradition for the Nasties in WCW, this is far too long, but not without charm. The stylistic contrast is engaging and there's a genuine chaos to the presentation, with Eaton and Regal playing to the champs' strengths. Their heat features bursts of quality too, it's just stretched a little thin unfortunately. **3/4"
[7.0] "Good match. Enjoyed this quite a bit as Regal and Eaton got to show how great they are. The fans were into this a ton and really liked the Nastys. Regal and Knobbs have this great exchange of forearms and punches. The Blue Bloods gimmick made for some entertaining bits but Regal and Eaton still turned it up a few notches during the body of the match. Eaton's flying knee still looked incredible here."
[5.0] "There's some of this enjoyable chaos typical to Nasties' matches, but most of the work still do Regal and Eaton. William's bumps looked great and both heels worked really hard to make the babyfaces look good, but I can't take away from Knobbs and Sags that they were over as hell at the time."
[5.0] "Die Titelverteidigung der Nasties verläuft im Grunde nicht besonders spektakulär, aber immerhin darf man mit Fug und Recht behaupten, dass sie heute auch gegen Gegner mit einem gewissen Selbstanspruch ins Feld ziehen. Eaton ist als Workhorse über jeden Zweifel erhaben, während Regal hier mit seiner Mimik für den einen oder anderen Lacher sorgt. Somit kommt trotz der hüftsteifen Nasties eine noch akzeptable Partie in die Bücher."
[7.0] "I don't hate the Nasty Boys like a lot of commenters do as I think they were very capable when they wanted to be....and here, it seems like they tried, just as Regal and Eaton did. Fun match between two contrasting teams."
[5.0] "Viel gebrawle (Überraschung) seitens der Nasty Boyz. Die Blue Bloods durften nicht zeigen, was sie können, aber großartiges Heel-Work und Mimik seitens Regal. Match war insgesamt ok."
[6.0] "Sounds crazy? But I liked this one! The Blue Bloods are a forgotten treasure of WCW comedy from 1995 and Regal could carry a lot of people in a singles match and Bobby Eaton is right at home carrying a tag match. They did a good job making for an entertaining match with the Nasties."
[6.0] "The amusement value of the newly ennobled Earl Robert Eaton being from Stoke-On-Trent might be lost on people less familiar with the Midlands, but it at least gives him a shared heritage with rock royalty such as Slash and Lemmy. This bout does make for a great clash of styles, and Lord Steven Regal is always amazing. Eaton is somewhat past his prime here, but is still better than 90% of wrestlers. The Nasties are their usual unpleasant selves, and even the Blue Bloods can't completely elevate them, but this is a fun brawl and the character work is top drawer. Regal's facial expressions alone a worth an extra point. Not a great match, but great (if childish) entertainment."
[9.0] "This is how unbelievably great the Blue Bloods are: they carried the Nasty Boys to a pretty great, no plunder match in 1995, of all things. I do believe this tag team could wrestle a broom and a mop to at least 3 stars."
