[3.0] "I feel bad seeing where his life has led him. He's screwing over fans and promoters, and one can only assume why he needs bits of cash here & there. Unfortunately his career wasn't special. I had no clue why ECW let him be champ, but it was on the tail end of the promotion so thats probably part of it. His WWE run showed he couldn't actually wrestle or work a crowd"
[5.0] "Shane Douglas' pet rat that got a wish to be a real boy. If Shane Douglas was your first e-fed character, Credible was your first CAW. Nice moveset. None of it was his, but it was a nice moveset. No personality. Solid, but way overpushed in ECW."
[4.0] "Says more about the state of ECW than his ability that they put the title on him about a year before going under. Somehow main evented, usually going over in awful matches to mass apathy, and was a perennial jobber elsewhere. Justin Jobber if you will. To think, Funk, Sabu, Raven, Taz, Dreamer and this chump. On the upside, maybe generated a small amount of business for manufacturers of Kendo Sticks for a couple years and that's about it."
[9.0] "Justin credible is one of the most underrated wrestlers in ecw, he definitely had one of the most entertaining gimmicks in the later stage of the company. I really loved his work with impact players especially their match against rob van dam and jerry lynn"
[4.0] "Very bland lower card talent. Started off as a jobber in the early 90's WWF, got repackaged into Aldo Montoya and was constantly clowned for his costume, then went to ECW and became the main eventer and even ECW champ, but ECW was in it's dying days so he was often looked at as a weak paper champion. Went to the WWF and became a member of X-Pac's stable (seriously? That guy deserved a stable? ) then just kinda hung around until late 2002 doing crappy hardcore match run ins."
[5.0] "I said about Shawn Stasiak "what's the probkem in being entertaining even if you're not a good worker? ", Well, here comes the other problem of the coin. What's the point in being a good worker if you're cringe and boring? But still, his look and gimmick was so ripped off that he deserves some credit. He lost some edge by the end of the 2000s but regained by the time Hardcore Justice 2010 rolled around. Strange he wasn't picked by anybody during those years, he was still only 37"
[5.0] "Arguably ECW's weakest world champion, he had a great name... that was it. The only thing he had was a great in-ring name and while he was a great heel in his own right, he wasn't main event material and his world title reign showed that he wasn't a GOOD choice to be a member of your main event scene."
[6.0] "Credible was, unfortunately, one of those kinds of wrestlers you could only really see reach their potential in ECW. His work there as part of the Impact Players was great heel work, and he managed to eventually outgrow his previous gimmick as the infamously shit "Aldo Montoya." He slowly managed to work his way through much of the established ECW faithful, by hook or by crook and often with the help of his partner Lance Storm. Beating Sandman, Sabu, Whipwreck and others before eventually toppling the hero Tommy Dreamer to get his one and only World Title."
[7.0] "Justin Credible was certainly over pushed in ECW, but that's more down to Paul Heyman misunderstanding what his audience wanted rather than any fault of Credible himself. Credible was a polished in-ring performer who had numerous good matches with the likes of Jerry Lynn and Tommy Dreamer. No, he shouldn't have been pushed as the top guy in the promotion, but he more than carried his end of things in the ring and he was a solid upper-mid-card attraction that could have a good match with a variety of different opponents. His run in ROH was good as well, as he had solid matches and often tried to make the up and coming stars like Matt Stryker look good in order to elevate them. Credible was a selfless worker who always put the match first and it's ultimately not his fault that Paul Heyman decided to push him so strongly"
[7.0] "Better than people are making him out to be. The impact players were a good tag team and Credible was a decent top of the card guy. Champ? No, they should have given it to Lance Storm. Same with WCW! But Credible wasn't good enough to be a long time title holder like they had him. I think Heyman was just being cheap. Although he had some decent matchups with Dreamer and a few others."
[5.0] "Justin Credible had possibly the greatest name in wrestling history. He didn't have a great look, cut amazing promos, or put on any 5-star classics. His move set was limited because he was a jobber most of his career and he didn't need many moves because he was always putting someone else over. However, he was pushed to the world title in the last year of ECW. It's kind of telling that every company Justin worked outside of ECW treated him like a jobber. He was basically the personification of an average wrestler."
[3.0] "Enhancement talent level performer who devalued the ECW title and brought the company down as a whole. I can only recommend matches involving Francine, because - duh Francine. Before AND after ECW he was enhancement talent for Vince. *sigh* but since i never cared about him ever, even a victory over him meant nothing - losing to Justin Credible/PJ Walker/Aldo Montoya seemed UNTHINKABLE but has actually *gasp* occurred. Not a fan, there's better enhancement talent FOR SURE. All points earned on the chest of Francine."
[7.0] "A former world champion. I am not sure he could have earned that status anywhere but ECW but I think he carried his weight in the tag division and the main event. He was a good enough worker to be carried over into WWE and WWE ECW but perhaps not special enough to get much further than the undercard and Hardcore division. It? s a shame that he has struggled with personal issues and demons, which in addition to being tragic for any individual may have eaten up the final years of his prime. I? m glad he? s still around and boy did I hate him for taking the title off of Tommy Dreamer!"
[3.0] "He gets 2 points for his name and 1 point for the promo the guy below me delivered lol. He is one of those guys I remember yet I don? t. Went through his match guide to try to stir up some memories and everything was blah nothing personal against the guy but he never did much to entertain me. There isn? t one thing he? s done that I could recommend going back and checking out."
[10.0] "Giving 10 for the name alone. No achievement or event in this world will ever come close to the perfect moment that is when the name justin credible was created. We peaked as a society when justin credible was created and justin credible transcends wrestling no reality itself. This is such a perfect moment i will name all my children justin credible follower 1, 2, 3 etc and create a cult of justin credible followers. Even anti vaxers and non mask wearers with 0 iq realize the intellegence and perfection of justin credible as he is justin credible not merely just another pathetic name. If justin credible came to grace us in WWE, NJPW or AEW he would single handedly end this pandemic, solve world hunger and create a distant utopia where all of our children and future generations would be named justin credible and achieve unprecedent perfection too the point where we would have to change the word perfection to justin credible cause that is what he is the very defintion of. In conclusion none of us will ever accomplish anything in life because it is all meaningless in the grand scheme of things when the name justin credible was created as justin credible... is just incredible."
[6.0] "Aldo Montoya -- the man with a jock strap on his face. How can you not laugh at that? But obviously, that's not really who we're looking at here. As Credible, I really thought he was not too bad. Even as a top player in ECW I thought he could hang. He shined brightest with the Impact Players. His return to WWE was less than stellar, but he was not an eyesore any time he showed up."
[6.0] "Justin Credible gets a lot of flack over his run as ECW world champion, and because of that, people overlook that Credible wasn't actually a bad wrestler. He was your prototypical 'good hand', the guy who could get a good match out of a total stiff. The problem is that a guy like that just shouldn't be your main singles champion. Credible's place was in the middle of the card not at the top of it."
[4.0] "Leider war für mich die Karriere mit dem Gimmick des "Portuguese Man-O-War" schon zu Ende. Den Hardcore Wrestler Justin Credible konnte ich ihm dann überhaupt nicht mehr abnehmen, schon damals nicht."
[4.0] "Justin Credible was a great mid-card/tag team wrestler. As a main-event singles wrestler, he had no place. Regardless, Justin Credible is Just Mediocre. His overhaul of a push made the last few years of ECW quite unbearable at times."
[4.0] "As a teacher I think Justin Credible would be great. The dude has a lot of good videos on youtube about wrestling, becoming a wrestler, and so on. As a talent? Ehh hes alright. Not worth being a Heavyweight Champ, and that he was speaks well for the group of talent ECW had at the end, but he knows how to work well enough. He should probably become a full time wrestling trainer if he hasn't already."
[6.0] "I enjoyed his work as half of the Impact Players (albeit the lesser half by far), but his main event push in ECW's dying days had more to do with ECW's depleted roster than with Credible actually being a legit main event type talent."
[7.0] "Justin Credible was a solid midcard heel act, both as a single and tag wrestler, who happened to be at the right place at the right time to get a run with the ECW World Title. His in-ring work was fine and showed a good amount of charisma in portraying a nasty heel character and did well in generating heat from the crowd. Arguably his most memorable run was as half of the Impact Players tag team with Lance Storm. Also seems to have a good mind for the business, as shown in his "Pro Wrestling 101" video series, and could be a valuable backstage addition to a promotion after his in-ring career is over."
[3.0] "Justin Credible isn't very memorable. Yeah that was a pretty bad pun but, I can barely remember anything about this guy at all. His wrestling career overall is barely worth noting, through and through."
[8.0] "There is little to no doubt that Justin Credible's best year in Pro wrestling was the year 2000, when at 1 point he was both the ECW tag team and ECW world heavyweight champion. While he also has had some terrible years, such as his 2 runs in WWE, it doesn't mean the guy is a bad wrestler. In fact, from a quality in foundation standpoint, Justin Credible is very underrated. Trained by the Hart Family, this guy is a quality worker and an excellent seller. To say the least, he knows the business well. An 8 from me, because he is an excellent worker, but 2 points off because as far as in-ring offence is concerned, he was good, but not outstanding."
[6.0] "In der ECW an der Seite von Lance Storm echt sehr stark, insgesamt in Hardcore Brawls gut aufgehoben. Aber in rein technischen Matches eher langweilig als atemberaubend, schlecht ist er aber auf keinen Fall, 6 Punkte."
[4.0] "Wie man so wenig aus sich machen kann, bei so viel Talent, ist mir unbegreiflich. Das in der WWF mit peinlichem Portugisen-Gimmick nichts ging, ist ja fast noch verständlich. In der ECW wurde er aber punktgenau platziert von Heyman, hätte also für wirklich große Ligen einen Anreiz darstellen müssen. Für das sichtbare Potential gäbe es 8/10 von mir, leider kann man es bei so einer schlechten Karriereentwicklung nicht guten Gewissens dabei belassen. Wenn man sich nirgends jemals dauerhaft durchsetzt, hat das seinen Grund, auch wenn er nicht an der Oberfläche ersichtlich ist."
[5.0] "Man-O-War........ Aldo Montoya...... geniales Gimmick was sich ideal in die WWF der 90er einfügte. Zu dumm nur, dass unter der Maske ein Mann steckte der eig. Besseres verdient hätte. Nur in der ECW wirklich wertvoll."
[6.0] "WWF Jobber, dann in der ECW aber großartig. Konnte sich in der McMahon Liga dann leider wiederum nicht durchsetzen. Auf jeden Fall ein guter Wrestler."
[5.0] "Mittelmäsiger Worker. Aldo Montoya hatte was und in der ECW wurde sein Talent erst richtig ausgeschöpft. Doch für so gut halte ich ihn nicht und ich verstehe nicht wieso gerade er völlig unverdient zum ECW Champion gemacht wurde."
[2.0] "Grausam Grausam... Ich habe keine Ahnung wie es in der Orginal ECW wohl zuging, aber scheinbar konnte man sich zum HW Champ wohl hochschlafen. Trotz aufbau durch Funk UND Dreamer konnte er mich nie wirklich überzeugen."
[4.0] "In der ECW bei den Impact Players legendär, aber sonst hat er nie etwas Großes gerissen. Ich finde auch langweilig und kann nicht viel mit ihm anfangen."
[2.0] "In der ECW war er ganz brauchbar aber außerhalb schaffte er nie den Durchbruch. In der WWE war er trotz Jobberstatus langweilig und bei seinen ROH Matches bin ich eingeschlafen."
[6.0] "Sieht eigentlich ganz gut aus. Habe bis jetzt aber nur ein paar wenige Matches von ihm in der ECW & WWE gesehen. Konnte mich nicht ganz überzeugen..."
[6.0] "Kein schlechter Techniker, aber dennoch bleibt er für mich einer der schlechteste ECW Champions die es je gab. Ihm fehlt das gewisse Etwas. Als Impact Players mit Lance Storm hat er mir dagegen ganz gut gefallen."
[6.0] "Talentiert, aber ihm fehlte einfach schon immer der eigene Antrieb. In der ECW als Forschungsprojekt von Paul Heyman gepusht ohne Ende. Dennoch gibt er zu, niemals eigene Ideen in sein Gimmick oder seine Storys eingebracht zu haben (obwohl das gerde unter Paul E möglich gewesen wäre)... so kann das ja nichts werden..."
