[8.0] "What started as a doomed preacher gimmick transformed into one of the most successful and beloved factions in wrestling history. Big E, Kofi, and Xavier Woods combined charisma, elite promo skills, and a genuine brotherhood that broke the mold of what a wrestling stable could be. They blended comedy with serious in-ring work, shattered merchandise records, and held the longest WWE Tag Team Title reign ever. More than just titles, they created a culture--pancakes, unicorn horns, and positivity--with real staying power. Even when Big E went solo, the bond stayed intact, making their unity more authentic than most. Top 5 stable of all-time without question. Between them and the Shield for best of the modern era. Not loving the current heel run without Big E, but as a trio they're undeniable"
[10.0] "My favorite tag team/stable of all time. The New Day were never supposed to be this great, but they got there off pure hard work and dedication."
[6.0] "So they go heel, and its great, but then they just like...stopped? everything? stopped having good matches, stop looking they cared, and we have enough of that already on Raw with the tag team division so quite frankly id rather them like, get it together or just quit it already, preferably the former because I know they can be great and still have it in them."
[9.0] "One of my favorite tag teams of all time. They never fail to impress with comedic genius and fantastic in-ring skills. I would love to see another tag team championship run, even though it will never be the same without Big E. So many memorable moments came from these goofballs, and I can't wait to see what they'll do next."
[6.0] "They're okay.... but "one of the greatest tag teams of all time"? Yeah right, give me a break. There is absolutely nothing about the new day that even puts them close to being in that category. Their in ring work was never even close to being top tier, and same can be said for their promo skills .... at least the latter is somewhat interesting now that they've dropped their completely lame and corny gimmick."
[8.0] "New Day is one of the greatest trios of all time. Without Big E it does feel like they are missing something so since this is rating the duo it will be a bit different. They are great in the ring and on the mic still. They still get a reaction from the crowd every time."
[6.0] "I don't know but they seems to me very cartoonish. And I don't think their wrestling is overall great. I think some heelturn and gimmick change (like it was with the usos) could bring the big deal for them"
[4.0] "They are not shitty competitors. In fact, Kofi and Xavier are great players. But I can't stand New Day as a team any longer, their time is gone. When I hear their entrance theme all I want is to skip to the next match/segment in the show."
[10.0] "Natürlich fehlt dieser New Day-Konstellation ohne Big E oftmals ziemlich viel Power. Aber auch ohne ihn können Woods und Kofi mich voll und ganz überzeugen. Die Zwei machen genau da weiter, wo das Trio aufgehört hat - sie unterhalten mich sehr gut. Aufgrund des Kultstatus natürlich etwas unterhalb des originalen Dreier-Teams anzusiedeln, aber letztendlich für mich immer noch die Höchstpunktzahl."
[10.0] "This is a team that should not have clicked but it somehow did. They have put up a great legacy, they will probably be signed to a legends contract when it is all said and done."
[9.0] "Regardless of personal opinion (I personally don't care for the gimmick and think that it's starting to get a little old), you can't deny how that have made originally a really crappy gimmick and made it into what it is today. Almost a phenomenon. They can be entertaining in the ring and have found major success... and they've stayed together for over 10 years. In WWE world, that's a rarity to accomplish that without a formal breakup. Give them credit where credit is due."
[8.0] "New Day as a team of two - without Big E it's worse New Day. I think everyone will agree with that. These three are perfect when they are together and any loss is felt. Only maybe Xavier is gaining a little from it - when there were three of them he was a bit behind, now he gets as much spotlight as Kofi."
[10.0] "Definitely don't understand how this differs from other people's ratings. The new day is quite literally the freebirds of this generation. So so many Tag Team titles. Two former world champions (hopefully one more). Lots and lots of merchandise money made. But most importantly a lot of very happy memories."
[10.0] "Specifically this is my version of the New Day tag team but I'm not saying I don't like a Big E combo, I just really like Woods as a character and his combo with Kofi."
[10.0] "One of the greatest tag teams in WWE history. They managed to keep things interesting over all these years. They deliver entertaining segments as well as good in-ring-work. Will be missed once they're gone"
[6.0] "They've drawn money and sold a lot of merch, but I'm just not a fan of their corny comedy act. They're stale AF by now. One of them should turn heel already."
[3.0] "If I started get tired of New Day when Big E was on it, imagine how disgusted and tired I am with the bored Kofi and too ridiculous Woods. Stop it, just stop is time to stop. If they are clowns and they are satisfied and comfortable with that role, put them chasing for the 24/7 title."
[7.0] "Big E als teils obszöner New Day-Pausenclown hat mir nie wirklich gefallen und funktionierte nur als Heel für mich wirklich gut. Die Konstellation ohne Big E funktioniert für mich daher schon per se gut, aber der bisherige Run war überschaubar. Das Booking hält die Herren bis zur Lashley-Fehde etwas im Hintergrund, aber im Zusammenspiel am Mikro und im Ring läuft es bei den Beiden immer noch. Das gewisse Etwas bleibt aber doch häufiger mal aus."
